The Conversation Articles: 1.13.25

Source: The Conversation

January 13, 2025

Top headlines

Lead story

Genetics influences a number of traits beyond your control: the color of your eyes, the angle of your ears, the curl of your tongue. For many other traits, however, social and environmental factors play a substantially larger role than the genes you’re born with – the material resources you have can make it easier or harder to pursue higher education, or the sports training you’ve undergone conditions your performance in competition.

Genes alone don’t determine someone’s likelihood to commit a crime or their socioeconomic status. But President-elect Donald Trump has pledged to enact mass deportations upon assuming office, claiming to protect the American public from immigrants bringing “bad genes” into the country.

With this week’s confirmation hearing for the secretary of Homeland Security – the government official leading U.S. immigration policy – disentangling rhetoric from evidence is key to getting a clear picture of what’s at stake. In today’s lead story, Shoumita Dasgupta, a geneticist at Boston University, explains America’s long history of misusing biology to justify violent acts and biased laws.

“Attempting to use science to explain human difference in ways that reinforce social hierarchies isn’t new,” Dasgupta writes. “It takes the playbooks of genetic essentialism and scientific racism and applies them to public policy.”

Mass deportations don’t keep out ‘bad genes’ − they use scientific racism to justify biased immigration policies

Shoumita Dasgupta, Boston University

The US has a long history of misusing genetics and biology in immigration policy, the effects of which are still keenly felt today.

Environment + Energy

Politics + Society

Economy + Business

Science + Technology

Discuss

OnAir membership is required. The lead Moderator for the discussions is US onAir Curator. We encourage civil, honest, and safe discourse. For more information on commenting and giving feedback, see our Comment Guidelines.

This is an open discussion on this news piece.

Home Forums Open Discussion

Viewing 1 post (of 1 total)
Viewing 1 post (of 1 total)
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.
Skip to toolbar